Focus on the BIG picture.
Friday, Apr 25, 2025

Greenpeace Ordered to Pay Hundreds of Millions Over Dakota Pipeline Protests

Greenpeace Ordered to Pay Hundreds of Millions Over Dakota Pipeline Protests

A North Dakota jury rules in favor of Energy Transfer, holding Greenpeace liable for defamation linked to protests at the Dakota Access pipeline.
A jury in Mandan, North Dakota, has ruled that Greenpeace must pay hundreds of millions of dollars to Energy Transfer Partners, a Dallas-based oil and gas company, after determining the environmental organization was liable for defamation and other claims related to protests against the Dakota Access pipeline in 2016 and 2017. Energy Transfer had sought $300 million, accusing Greenpeace of inciting protests through a misinformation campaign that allegedly led to criminal behavior amongst demonstrators.

The jury found in favor of Energy Transfer on most counts, raising significant concerns among free speech advocates regarding the implications of the ruling for future activism and the right to protest.

Greenpeace, which has denied the allegations made against it, stated that such lawsuits threaten the constitutional right to peaceful protest.

Legal experts have voiced apprehensions that the case could impose a chilling effect on free speech, particularly for non-profits engaged in advocacy.

Greenpeace expressed anxiety before the trial regarding its ability to secure a fair hearing in a region heavily influenced by the fossil fuel industry.

In the aftermath of the verdict, Greenpeace highlighted the potential financial repercussions of the ruling, stating that the damages awarded could threaten its U.S. operations.

The company pursued legal action against three entities associated with Greenpeace, alleging that they operate as a single organization rather than independent branches.

As of now, it remains unclear whether Greenpeace will seek to appeal the verdict.

The case has drawn significant attention from the nonprofit sector and First Amendment experts, who are monitoring its implications for activism across the United States.

Greenpeace's senior legal adviser, Deepa Padmanabha, criticized the approach taken by Energy Transfer during the trial, which she claimed disregarded the voices of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, a principal group involved in the protests.

Padmanabha emphasized the organization's commitment to nonviolence and its determination to challenge actions perceived as undermining rights to peaceful expression.

Greenpeace’s general counsel, Kristin Casper, affirmed that the organization would continue its legal battle, planning to file an anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) lawsuit against Energy Transfer’s claims regarding free speech and peaceful protest.

Energy Transfer issued a statement expressing satisfaction with the jury’s decision.

The company described the verdict as a victory for the residents of North Dakota who endured disruptions and harassment from protesters supported by Greenpeace, asserting that the ruling upheld the distinction between lawful free speech and unlawful protest actions.

The trial highlighted the challenges of jury selection in a politically conservative area with strong connections to the fossil fuel sector.

Many jurors had ties to the industry and voiced disapproval of the protests, which compounded concerns about the fairness of the proceedings.

Attempts by Greenpeace to relocate the trial to a different venue within North Dakota were denied.

Legal experts have suggested that the case exemplifies a SLAPP lawsuit, a legal strategy designed to intimidate critics, resulting in considerable legal costs and potential silence for dissenting voices.

The five-week trial saw efforts by Energy Transfer to associate a range of disruptions caused by protests directly with Greenpeace, despite the latter maintaining its limited involvement at the request of the Standing Rock Tribe.

The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe has publicly stated that it spearheaded the protests against the pipeline and has indicated difficulty in obtaining safety information from Energy Transfer.

The tribe characterized the lawsuit as an attempt to suppress its voice and the pressing concerns over the pipeline’s impacts on its land and water resources.

In the trial's concluding days, Energy Transfer’s founder, Kelcy Warren, revealed in a video deposition that inducements had been offered to the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe to halt protests, including financial incentives and infrastructure offerings, which the tribe reportedly declined in favor of legal counsel provided by Earthjustice.

A monitoring committee overseeing the trial has sought to address concerns regarding due process, asserting that the proceedings were fundamentally flawed and that the jury demonstrated a bias favoring Energy Transfer.

Prominent First Amendment attorney Marty Garbus stated the trial lacked fairness, suggesting that Greenpeace possesses a robust basis for appeal.

Energy Transfer initially filed a RICO lawsuit in federal court in 2017, which was dismissed.

A similar case was subsequently refiled in North Dakota state court a week later.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
U.S. Intelligence Chief Refers Classified Leak Cases to Justice Department
U.S. Justice Department and DOGE Announce Cuts to Federal Grants Amid Broader Government Efficiency Efforts
Trump administration moves to BAN essentially ALL artificial food dyes in the USA food supply at RFK Jr.'s direction
Woman slaps man at sports game and gets herself and husband beat up
Pope Francis: head of the Catholic church who pushed for social and economic justice
China do not pay these tariffs - you pay it. This is new 145% tax you pay to the US government.
The legacy media will never show you this side of President Trump
In God We Profit
Cultural Battles in the Vatican: The Candidates in the Battle for the Holy See and Pope Francis's Testament
Global Leaders Pay Tribute to Pope Francis Following His Death
Wild Chimpanzees Observed Bonding Over Alcoholic Fruit
Greek Christians Celebrate Easter in Thessaloníki
US Federal Reserve Chair Issues Warning on Tariff Impact
UK Prison Officers Demand Electric Stun Guns Amid Safety Concerns
China, China, China!
El Salvador Proposes Prisoner Exchange with Venezuela Amid Deportation Controversy
US Government Defends Deportation of Salvadoran National Kilmar Abrego Garcia
Australian National Charged as Mercenary for Fighting in Ukraine
Israel Considers Limited Strikes on Iran's Nuclear Facilities Amid Diplomatic Efforts
A casino in Mexico burns at the hands of cartels
Prince Andrew Joins Royal Family Attends Easter Sunday Service at Windsor Castle
Pope Francis Makes Brief Appearance at Easter Sunday Mass
Saudi Arabia Offers Max Verstappen Unprecedented Deal to Join Aston Martin
Global Pistachio Shortage Amid Rising Demand for 'Dubai Chocolate'
Trump is assembling a coalition of Western leaders aligned with the MAGA vision, strengthening a unified front for global change
IMF Predicts No Global Recession Amid Trade Tensions
Alphabet Faces Antitrust Setbacks as Federal Judges Rule Against Google
Here’s a police officer with a brilliant gift for swift education
Britain, as is well known, was never truly a democracy, but today it has even stopped bothering to pretend that it is
"Some complain that we put thousands in prison. In reality, we set millions free."
US Billionaires Call for Higher Taxes, but Proposed 'Millionaires Tax' May Not Achieve Desired Outcome
This is Vienna, Austria in 2025.
Designed in US, made in China: Why Apple is stuck in tariff tussle
Boeing Jet Returns to US from China Amid Tariff War
Canadian Federal Election: Candidates' Positions on US-Canada Relations and Donald Trump
Resentencing Hearing for Menendez Brothers Who Killed Their Parents Delayed Amid Legal Disputes
Australian Woman Gives Birth To Stranger's Baby In IVF Mix-up
US Sets Deadline for Russia-Ukraine Peace Deal Brokerage
Italy Introduces 'Sex Rooms' in Prisons for Inmates
US Government to Reclassify Career Employees Working on Policy Matters
U.S. Appeals Court Upholds Massachusetts Assault Weapons Ban
NBA Coach Steve Kerr Backs Harvard Amid Trump Administration's Federal Funding Freeze
California Launches Legal Challenge Against Trump Administration's Tariffs
US-China Trade War: Trump Expects 'Very Good Deal' Amid Escalating Tariffs
"Groundless": China Dismisses Zelensky's Claims It's Supplying Arms To Russia
US Judge Blocks Trump Administration's Rapid Deportation Policy
French Far-Right Writer Renaud Camus Denied Entry to UK
UK Police Force Updates Search Policy for Trans Individuals in Custody
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni Meets with Donald Trump to Discuss EU-US Trade Tensions
China's Largest iPhone Factory Resumes Hiring After Tariff Exemption
×