A prominent activist's arrest during the Gaza war protests raises significant legal and free speech concerns in the United States.
Mahmoud Khalil, a prominent Palestinian activist and Columbia University graduate, remains in detention in Louisiana, following his arrest by immigration agents linked to a crackdown on student protests amid the Gaza war in 2024. Born in Syria to Palestinian refugees, Khalil has drawn international attention as part of a broader discourse surrounding free speech on U.S. college campuses and the implications for permanent residents.
Khalil's arrest was orchestrated by the Trump administration amid claims that pro-Palestinian demonstrations were aligned with Hamas, which is classified as a terrorist organization by the U.S. Trump previously stated that these protests were 'un-American' and suggested that deportations of demonstrators would follow.
In a court hearing on Wednesday, Mr. Khalil's legal team argued for his release and against the revocation of his green card.
A federal judge temporarily blocked his deportation, allowing a further examination of the case.
However, Khalil remains detained without any criminal charges filed against him.
Before immigrating to the U.S. in 2022, Khalil earned a computer science degree from the Lebanese American University and worked for the Syrian-American non-profit Jusoor, as well as managing the Syria Chevening Programme for the British Embassy in Beirut.
Most recently, he obtained a master's degree at Columbia University and was living with his American wife, who is currently eight months pregnant.
Khalil's involvement in the 2024 protests at Columbia positioned him as a key figure during negotiations between activists and university officials.
He reportedly served as a spokesperson and mediator but denied leading the Columbia University Apartheid Divest (Cuad) group, which advocated for the university to divest from Israel and called for a ceasefire in Gaza.
Following Khalil's arrest, the Department of Homeland Security accused him of 'leading activities aligned to Hamas', though no specific evidence has been made public.
The White House has alleged he organized protests in which pro-Hamas propaganda was distributed, while his legal representatives maintain that he has not supported any designated terror groups.
The protests at Columbia, which have sparked significant dialogue about antisemitism on campus, drew mixed reactions.
Some Jewish students reported feeling unsafe, while many students from diverse backgrounds participated in the protests.
In response to the unrest at Columbia, the Trump administration reduced grants to the institution over claims of insufficient action against harassment of Jewish students.
Khalil's case is noteworthy as it marks a potential precedent in targeting permanent residents for deportation under national security claims based on their political activism.
Legal experts have commented that such actions against individual protesters have not commonly occurred in the United States, raising ongoing concerns about the stifling of dissent.
Khalil had previously faced scrutiny at Columbia during the protests, resulting in a brief suspension from the university, which he attributed to a lack of evidence.
His wife has expressed fears regarding the implications of his arrest, stating that he grew increasingly worried about deportation prior to his detention.
The uproar following Khalil's arrest has mobilized protests in New York City, with numerous participants expressing solidarity with his cause.
Advocacy groups, including the New York Civil Liberties Union and the American Civil Liberties Union, have characterized the attempted deportation as a direct attack on free speech in the United States.
In defense of the action, the White House maintains that it will not endorse residency privileges for individuals advocating positions it deems supportive of terrorism.