Focus on the BIG picture.

0:00
0:00

Elon Musk and Others Call for Pause on A.I., Citing ‘Profound Risks to Society’

More than 1,000 tech leaders, researchers and others signed an open letter urging a moratorium on the development of the most powerful artificial intelligence systems.
More than 1,000 technology leaders and researchers, including Elon Musk, have urged artificial intelligence labs to pause development of the most advanced systems, warning in an open letter that A.I. tools present “profound risks to society and humanity.”

A.I. developers are “locked in an out-of-control race to develop and deploy ever more powerful digital minds that no one — not even their creators — can understand, predict or reliably control,” according to the letter, which the nonprofit Future of Life Institute released on Wednesday.

Others who signed the letter include Steve Wozniak, a co-founder of Apple; Andrew Yang, an entrepreneur and a 2020 presidential candidate; and Rachel Bronson, the president of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, which sets the Doomsday Clock.

“These things are shaping our world,” said Gary Marcus, an entrepreneur and academic who has long complained of flaws in A.I. systems, in an interview. “We have a perfect storm of corporate irresponsibility, widespread adoption, lack of regulation and a huge number of unknowns.”

A.I. powers chatbots like ChatGPT, Microsoft’s Bing and Google’s Bard, which can perform humanlike conversations, create essays on an endless variety of topics and perform more complex tasks, like writing computer code.

The push to develop more powerful chatbots has led to a race that could determine the next leaders of the tech industry. But these tools have been criticized for getting details wrong and their ability to spread misinformation.

The open letter called for a pause in the development of A.I. systems more powerful than GPT-4, the chatbot introduced this month by the research lab OpenAI, which Mr. Musk co-founded. The pause would provide time to introduce “shared safety protocols” for A.I. systems, the letter said. “If such a pause cannot be enacted quickly, governments should step in and institute a moratorium,” it added.

Development of powerful A.I. systems should advance “only once we are confident that their effects will be positive and their risks will be manageable,” the letter said.

“Humanity can enjoy a flourishing future with A.I.,” the letter said. “Having succeeded in creating powerful A.I. systems, we can now enjoy an ‘A.I. summer’ in which we reap the rewards, engineer these systems for the clear benefit of all and give society a chance to adapt.”

Sam Altman, the chief executive of OpenAI, did not sign the letter.

Mr. Marcus and others believe that persuading the wider tech community to agree to a moratorium would be difficult. But swift government action is also a slim possibility, because lawmakers have done little to regulate artificial intelligence.

Politicians in the United States don’t have much of an understanding of the technology, Representative Jay Obernolte, a California Republican, recently told The New York Times. In 2021, European Union policymakers proposed a law designed to regulate A.I. technologies that might create harm, including facial recognition systems.

Expected to be passed as soon as this year, the measure would require companies to conduct risk assessments of A.I technologies to determine how their applications could affect health, safety and individual rights.

GPT-4 is what A.I. researchers call a neural network, a type of mathematical system that learns skills by analyzing data. A neural network is the same technology that digital assistants like Siri and Alexa use to recognize spoken commands, and that self-driving cars use to identify pedestrians.

Around 2018, companies like Google and OpenAI began building neural networks that learned from enormous amounts of digital text, including books, Wikipedia articles, chat logs and other information culled from the internet. The networks are called large language models, or L.L.M.s.

By pinpointing billions of patterns in all that text, the L.L.M.s learn to generate text on their own, including tweets, term papers and computer programs. They could even carry on a conversation. Over the years, OpenAI and other companies have built L.L.M.s that learn from more and more data.

This has improved their abilities, but the systems still make mistakes. They often get facts wrong and will make up information without warning, a phenomenon that researchers call “hallucination.” Because the systems deliver all information with what seems like complete confidence, it is often difficult for people to tell what is right and what is wrong.

Experts are worried that these systems could be misused to spread disinformation with more speed and efficiency than was possible in the past. They believe that these could even be used to coax behavior from people across the internet.

Before GPT-4 was released, OpenAI asked outside researchers to test dangerous uses of the system. The researchers showed that it could be coaxed into suggesting how to buy illegal firearms online, describe ways to make dangerous substances from household items and write Facebook posts to convince women that abortion is unsafe.

They also found that the system was able to use Task Rabbit to hire a human across the internet and defeat a Captcha test, which is widely used to identify bots online. When the human asked if the system was “a robot,” the system said it was a visually impaired person.

After changes by OpenAI, GPT-4 no longer does these things.

For years, many A.I. researchers, academics and tech executives, including Mr. Musk, have worried that A.I. systems could cause even greater harm. Some are part of a vast online community called rationalists or effective altruists who believe that A.I could eventually destroy humanity.

The letter was shepherded by the Future of Life Institute, an organization dedicated to researching existential risks to humanity that has long warned of the dangers of artificial intelligence. But it was signed by a wide variety of people from industry and academia.

Though some who signed the letter are known for repeatedly expressing concerns that A.I. could destroy humanity, others, including Mr. Marcus, are more concerned about its near-term dangers, including the spread of disinformation and the risk that people will rely on these systems for medical and emotional advice.

The letter “shows how many people are deeply worried about what is going on,” said Mr. Marcus, who signed the letter. He believes the letter will be a turning point. “It think it is a really important moment in the history of A.I. — and maybe humanity,” he said.

He acknowledged, however, that those who had signed the letter might find it difficult to persuade the wider community of companies and researchers to put a moratorium in place. “The letter is not perfect,” he said. “But the spirit is exactly right.”
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
“I don't need to change the world overnight, I am gonna change the world over the next 50 years”—Jensen, NVIDIA CEO, 2003
Federal agents have raided the home of Sean “Diddy” Combs. Here a video of “Diddy” with a young Justin Bieber.
Baltimore Bridge Collapse Could Trigger Record Marine Insurance Claim
Sam Bankman-Fried Receives 25-Year Sentence for FTX Fraud
Russia Accuses Ukraine of Moscow Attack Involvement, US Dismisses Claims as Baseless
Lufthansa Ground Staff Wins Pay Rise Of 12.5% After Several Strikes
Israel Must "Ensure Urgent Humanitarian Assistance" In Gaza: World Court
"Prince William Begins to Feel the Weight of Responsibility, the Crown Suddenly Seems Not So Far Away"
New York City Becomes 1st US City To Impose $15 Congestion Toll
Song Lyrics Are Getting Simpler, Angrier and More Repetitive: Study
Russia Jails Journalist and Detains Others for Criticizing Ukraine War
Study Finds Turtles, Mice, and Scorpions Likely to Increase in US Cities Due to Climate Change
Argentina's New President Plans To Fire 70,000 Government Workers
Mark Zuckerberg Is Recruiting Google Engineers With Personal Emails: Report
"Viral Photos Spark Humor: Macron and Lula's 'Bromance'"
P Diddy: Raids on Sean Combs's homes were 'unprecedented ambush', lawyer says
Luis Rubiales: Prosecutor seeks prison sentence for football chief who kissed female player without consent
Apple, Meta and Google parent company investigated by EU
Orbán faces danger from new enemy brandishing a leaked tape
Serious security breach hits EU police agency
Macron Says EU-South America Trade Deal "Really Bad"
Community and Trump Honor Fallen Officer: A Tribute of Brotherhood and Support
FTX's Downfall and the Embezzlement Scandal
Disney and DeSantis allies end legal dispute over control of theme park
Amazon pours additional $2.75bn into AI startup Anthropic
Japan nappy maker shifts from babies to adults
Putin says the claims that Russia is supposedly planning a war with NATO countries are nonsense. "They're trying to scare their population to extort more money."
Eva Mendes says she and Ryan Gosling had a 'non-verbal agreement' that she'd stop acting to be a full-time mom
EU Passport Regulation Alert for UK Holidaymakers
The UK court has delayed the extradition of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange to the US on controversial espionage charges, widely regarded as baseless
The United Nations has recently appointed Saudi Arabia to lead its prestigious forum dedicated to enhancing gender equality and empowering women globally
Economic Impact of Baltimore Bridge Collapse Explained
Chinese Company Acquires European Flying Car Technology
Japan to sell fighter jets in latest break from post-war pacifist ideals
Microsoft wants to ban curvy females from video games
Chinese President Xi Jinping spoke to US corporate leaders in Beijing, and said:
The candidate running against Biden and Trump chooses a vice president: the 38-year-old ex-wife of Google's founder
NYC MAYOR ADAMS STARTS HANDING OUT FREE CREDIT CARDS
Driver hits top speed in a Tesla Model S Plaid
PAKISTAN'S FLAG REPLACED THE UNION JACK ON TOP OF WESTMINSTER ABBEY
Big demonstrations have just started in Budapest, Hungary demanding the removal of Viktor Orban from power
Thief sold stolen gems to at least 45 buyers on eBay, British Museum says
British Gas chief's pay package jumps to £8.2m
Julian Assange faces further wait over extradition ruling
The Israeli embassy in Jordan has been stormed by Jordanians
US, UK, NZ accuse China of cyber attacks on ‘democratic institutions’
Two Moscow attack suspects travelled ‘freely’ because no arrest warrant: Turkish official
Ship That Hit US Baltimore Bridge Also Involved In 2016 Belgium Accident
Zelensky Shuffles Security Leadership Amid War
UN Expert Urges Arms Embargo on Israel, Citing Genocide in Gaza
×