Three Ex-Memphis Officers Acquitted of State Charges in Tyre Nichols Beating Case
A jury finds former officers not guilty of second-degree murder and other charges related to the 2023 death of Tyre Nichols.
On Wednesday, a jury in Memphis acquitted former police officers Tadarrius Bean, Demetrius Haley, and Justin Smith of state charges, including second-degree murder, in the death of Tyre Nichols, a Black man who died following a violent confrontation with police in January 2023. The jury deliberated for approximately eight and a half hours over two days before reaching its verdict after a nine-day trial.
The incident occurred after Nichols fled a traffic stop, leading to a pursuit by multiple officers.
Following his apprehension, he was subjected to physical violence, including punches, kicks, and strikes with a police baton.
Nichols ultimately succumbed to his injuries on January 10, 2023, three days after the beating, with medical reports indicating he suffered blunt force trauma, including tears and bleeding in the brain.
Following the jury's announcement, the defendants embraced their legal team as family members of the officers reacted emotionally to the verdict.
Despite their acquittal of state charges, they still await sentencing for federal convictions related to Nichols’s death.
Footage from the incident recorded by police cameras illustrated the brutality of the encounter, prompting nationwide protests and calls for police reform.
The five officers involved in the traffic stop were all Black and faced public scrutiny in a majority-Black city.
Former officer Desmond Mills Jr., who was also charged in the case, testified against his colleagues.
Mills and another officer, Emmitt Martin, are set to plead guilty to charges associated with Nichols's death in an agreement with prosecutors, which exempted them from trial.
The jury had evaluated charges against the three officers, which included second-degree murder, aggravated assault, aggravated kidnapping, official misconduct, and official oppression.
Prosecutors suggested that the officers acted out of frustration and adrenaline following Nichols's attempt to flee, asserting that they had a duty to intervene and prevent excessive force.
Defense attorneys maintained their clients acted within the bounds of law enforcement standards during the arrest, with portrayals of Mills expressing regret for not intervening.
Mills admitted on the stand that he used a police baton on Nichols in a moment of anger, while also asserting that Nichols was resisting arrest.
The defense's arguments included claims about Nichols's physical state during the encounter, suggesting he may have been under the influence of drugs, an assertion countered by a toxicology report showing only alcohol and minimal marijuana in his system at the time of his death.
Further complicating the narrative, Mills testified about his attempts to utilize pepper spray during the altercation, which he misapplied and ended up spraying himself.
Prosecutors contended that the officers made derogatory comments about Nichols following the beating, challenging the defense's stance that they were oblivious to the violence they were inflicting.
In December, an extensive investigation by the U.S. Justice Department revealed systemic issues within the Memphis Police Department, citing excessive use of force and racial discrimination against Black individuals, which galvanized discussions on law enforcement practices and accountability across the nation.