Focus on the BIG picture.

0:00
0:00

In a dramatic U-turn against His Government: Judicial Reform Legislation Must Be Halted, Says Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant

In a de facto coup d'état, Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant joined the opposition against his government on Saturday.
He called for an immediate and temporary halt to the government's plan to democratize the judiciary, marking the first public dissent from within Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's coalition.

Gallant cited the need for dialogue with the opposition, asking Netanyahu's coalition to wait until after the Jewish Passover holiday, which begins on April 5, before pushing ahead with its plan to reform the judiciary.

He expressed concerns that the reform plans pose a threat to the country's security.

And he is right.

As Minister of Defense, he has a duty to ensure the security of the state rather than prioritize the security of the coalition.

The call for a halt to the judiciary reform legislation is rooted in an urgent and perilous situation that poses a significant threat to the continued existence of Israel as a strong, prosperous, and stable nation.

To fully comprehend the scale and gravity of the issue at hand, it is crucial to distinguish between the facts and the misleading and manipulative propaganda that both sides propagate for their own self-interest.

A small group of elite legal administrators strongly opposes the democratization of the judicial system.

They benefit from the current status quo, which grants them absolute control over Israel's so-called 'democracy' through unelected bureaucratic absolute rule, without any external or independent checks, balances, controls, limits or the need to follow any public will.

They have effectively connected with two larger groups: the 27 percent that refuses to recognize Netanyahu's victory in the elections and the wider 55 percent that is secular and rejects the idea of being governed by a government controlled by Orthodox and right-wingers.

Together, these groups have created a critical mass of effective opposition against the legitimacy of the elected government in Israel.

This opposition has even led to the refusal of some members of intelligence and elite units to serve in the army, to divide the intelligence community from within and to an active movement of TeXit: Massive and successful tech companies are looking now to relocate all their R&D outside Israel, in exchange of zero-tax and instant citizenship deal. UK, UAE and Biden Administration are looking at this opportunity seriously.

For the first time since the War of Independence, the existence of the State of Israel is threatened not by external forces but by internal disputes and mutual hatred between the 12 Jewish tribes.

This might be the third time in history. The Jewish state has collapsed twice in the past due to internal conflicts and hatred among brothers. When you think about it deeply and historically, the ongoing Arab-Jewish conflict can also be seen as a conflict rooted in the feud between Jacob and Esau, who were the grandsons of Abraham, the sons of Isaac and Rebekah.

However, the elected government refuses to freeze the legislative process because it fears that the absolute power of the judicial system, which they are trying to reform, will invent criminal cases against the ministers involved in the legislation, only to suspend them from the ability to continue to legislate until they prove their innocence.

This process of proving the fake political neutralizing takes years and has already happened 12 times in the past.

And as an Israeli poet named Yehuda Amichai once wrote, precisely in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, but it is also very true for the current situation: in a place where everyone is right, flowers will never bloom in the spring.

To ensure the continued existence of a healthy, strong, and prosperous State of Israel, it is necessary to halt the legislation and engage in political negotiations between the coalition and the opposition.

Both sides agree on the need to reform the judicial system, but only under the condition that they are in power and can elect the judges.

However, to halt the legislation for negotiations to take place, the judicial system and all the bureaucrats who control it without any external checks, balances, or controls must sign a commitment stating that they will not demand the indictment or suspension of any members of the current government during the temporary freeze.

This commitment is crucial to ensure that halting the legislation is used for fair and open negotiations, and not as a ploy for legal bureaucrats to neutralize government members with fake criminal cases, as has happened 12 times over the past 20 years of attempted legal reform.

Disclaimer:
While I was originally supportive of the idea of reforming the judicial system, given the current circumstances, I've come to the conclusion that "If it works - don't fix it!".

Or in the words of Menachem Begin, the spiritual father of the current ruling party in Israel, "The difficulties of peace are better than the sufferings of war."






# Yariv Levin, # Benjamin Netanyahu, # Yoav Gallant, # Amir Ohana, # Shlomo Karhi, # Haim Ramon, # Prof. Yoav Sapir, # Kohelet Policy Forum, # Dr. Gadi Taub
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Study Finds Turtles, Mice, and Scorpions Likely to Increase in US Cities Due to Climate Change
Argentina's New President Plans To Fire 70,000 Government Workers
Mark Zuckerberg Is Recruiting Google Engineers With Personal Emails: Report
"Viral Photos Spark Humor: Macron and Lula's 'Bromance'"
P Diddy: Raids on Sean Combs's homes were 'unprecedented ambush', lawyer says
Luis Rubiales: Prosecutor seeks prison sentence for football chief who kissed female player without consent
Apple, Meta and Google parent company investigated by EU
Apple, Meta and Google parent company investigated by EU
Orbán faces danger from new enemy brandishing a leaked tape
Serious security breach hits EU police agency
Macron Says EU-South America Trade Deal "Really Bad"
Community and Trump Honor Fallen Officer: A Tribute of Brotherhood and Support
FTX's Downfall and the Embezzlement Scandal
Disney and DeSantis allies end legal dispute over control of theme park
Amazon pours additional $2.75bn into AI startup Anthropic
Japan nappy maker shifts from babies to adults
Putin says the claims that Russia is supposedly planning a war with NATO countries are nonsense. "They're trying to scare their population to extort more money."
Eva Mendes says she and Ryan Gosling had a 'non-verbal agreement' that she'd stop acting to be a full-time mom
EU Passport Regulation Alert for UK Holidaymakers
The UK court has delayed the extradition of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange to the US on controversial espionage charges, widely regarded as baseless
The United Nations has recently appointed Saudi Arabia to lead its prestigious forum dedicated to enhancing gender equality and empowering women globally
Economic Impact of Baltimore Bridge Collapse Explained
Chinese Company Acquires European Flying Car Technology
Japan to sell fighter jets in latest break from post-war pacifist ideals
Microsoft wants to ban curvy females from video games
Chinese President Xi Jinping spoke to US corporate leaders in Beijing, and said:
The candidate running against Biden and Trump chooses a vice president: the 38-year-old ex-wife of Google's founder
NYC MAYOR ADAMS STARTS HANDING OUT FREE CREDIT CARDS
Driver hits top speed in a Tesla Model S Plaid
PAKISTAN'S FLAG REPLACED THE UNION JACK ON TOP OF WESTMINSTER ABBEY
Big demonstrations have just started in Budapest, Hungary demanding the removal of Viktor Orban from power
Thief sold stolen gems to at least 45 buyers on eBay, British Museum says
British Gas chief's pay package jumps to £8.2m
Julian Assange faces further wait over extradition ruling
The Israeli embassy in Jordan has been stormed by Jordanians
US, UK, NZ accuse China of cyber attacks on ‘democratic institutions’
Two Moscow attack suspects travelled ‘freely’ because no arrest warrant: Turkish official
Ship That Hit US Baltimore Bridge Also Involved In 2016 Belgium Accident
Zelensky Shuffles Security Leadership Amid War
UN Expert Urges Arms Embargo on Israel, Citing Genocide in Gaza
British Museum Gets Court Order for Return of Stolen Artefacts
Saudi Arabia To Participate In Miss Universe Pageant For 1st Time Ever
Vodafone Germany Announces 2,000 Job Cuts in Restructuring Effort
US Judge Imposes Gag Order On Trump In New York Hush Money Case
South Korea security expo features AI sound detection, crowd control help
Very smart installation to educate pedestrians on how to cross the street.
Morning daylight uncovers the aftermath of the Scott Key Bridge collapse, a mass casualty event caused by a Singaporean cargo ship's crash
President Biden reveals that he took the train over the Francis Scott Key Bridge "many times" during his commute even though the bridge didn't have train tracks. Very impressive!
Donald Trump's net worth has soared to $6.5 billion, marking today as the most significant single-day gain in his wealth ever.
"Why do you always think that the way you live is better than the way we live?"
×